Slackactivity vs Idle Pilot: An Honest Comparison
Slackactivity is free forever and supports unlimited Slack workspaces; Idle Pilot is a paid subscription that covers Slack or Microsoft Teams, one connected platform at a time. If Slack is where your team lives, Slackactivity does the job at zero cost. If you need Microsoft Teams presence, Idle Pilot is the right tool and we'll happily point you there.
Feature Comparison at a Glance
Idle Pilot pricing and feature details below were taken from their public pricing and features pages at the time of writing. Prices change - verify before you buy.
| Feature | Slackactivity | Idle Pilot |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free forever. No card, no trial clock, no paid tier. | $9/month, or $60/year (about $5/month) billed annually. 7-day free trial, no card required. |
| Slack support | Yes | Yes |
| Microsoft Teams support | No - Slack only | Yes (one platform connected at a time) |
| Works with the laptop closed | Yes - cloud cron every 5 minutes | Yes - runs from their cloud servers |
| Unlimited workspaces | Yes - unlimited, one dashboard | No - one connected platform at a time |
| Per-workspace schedules | Yes - start hour, end hour, days and timezone per workspace | Per-day schedules and lunch breaks for the one connected account |
| Official Slack Web API | Yes - Slack OAuth and users.setPresence | Not documented publicly; setup is fastest via a Chrome extension |
| Install required | None - one OAuth click in the browser | Optional Chrome extension for the quick setup path; manual flow for other browsers |
| Vacation mode | Yes | Yes |
What Both Tools Get Right
Both products exist because of the same Slack behaviour: the desktop app flips your dot to gray after 30 minutes with no interaction inside Slack itself, and the mobile app goes away almost the instant you background it. Slack offers no setting to lengthen or disable that timeout on any plan - free, Pro, Business+ or Enterprise Grid. We explain the mechanics in why Slack shows you as away.
Both Slackactivity and Idle Pilot solve it the same sensible way: server-side. Neither one is a mouse jiggler, and neither depends on your machine staying awake. That is the important part. A jiggler or a caffeinate script dies the moment your laptop lid closes or your battery runs out, and simulated input is detectable by endpoint monitoring software. Cloud presence refreshes are not. Both tools also handle timezones properly and both offer a vacation mode so your status does not sit green through a week in Portugal.
Cloud, not your device
Both run presence from their own servers, so closing the laptop, switching machines or going offline doesn't break your status.
Timezone-aware schedules
Both let you define working hours and days rather than staying green 24/7, which is what makes the result look natural instead of suspicious.
Where Slackactivity Comes Out Ahead
Free forever, genuinely
No credit card, no trial that expires, no paid tier waiting behind a feature. Every capability on this page costs nothing, permanently. Idle Pilot is $9/month or $60/year at the time of writing.
Unlimited Slack workspaces
Connect your employer's workspace, a client's, a contractor community and a side project - all on one dashboard, each with its own hours. Idle Pilot documents one connected platform at a time.
Official Slack API, minimal scope
Slackactivity authorises through standard Slack OAuth and calls users.setPresence. The scope requested cannot read your messages, files or channels - it isn't technically able to.
Nothing to install
No desktop agent, no browser extension, no background process. Go to /signin, click Continue with Slack, set your hours. That's the whole setup.
The multi-workspace difference is bigger than it sounds. Plenty of people are in three or four Slacks: the day job, a client, an alumni community, an open-source project. With a one-account tool you either pick a favourite or pay again. Slackactivity treats every workspace as its own row with its own start hour, end hour, days of the week and timezone - useful if you contract for a European client in the morning and a US team in the afternoon. See how remote workers use it for real setups.
The transparency point matters too. Because Slackactivity uses Slack's own OAuth flow, you can see exactly which permissions you granted in Slack's app management screen, and revoke them there in one click without talking to us. There is no session token being captured, and nothing running on your machine to uninstall.
Where Idle Pilot Is the Better Choice
We are not going to pretend Idle Pilot has no advantages. It has a clear one, and for some readers it is decisive.
Microsoft Teams support
Idle Pilot handles Teams presence as well as Slack. Slackactivity does not support Teams at all. If your company runs on Teams, Idle Pilot is the tool to use - go get it.
Lunch break windows
Idle Pilot lets you carve a lunch break out of the middle of the working day, so your presence dips and returns. It's a nice touch if your team watches that closely.
Idle Pilot also advertises an activity history view and an instant off switch. If you are a Teams user, or you want a paid product with a support contract behind it, that is a perfectly reasonable purchase. Our pitch is narrower on purpose: Slack, done properly, for free, across as many workspaces as you have.
How Slackactivity Actually Keeps You Green
A cron job on our servers wakes up every 5 minutes. For each workspace you have connected, it checks whether the current time falls inside the work hours and days you configured for that workspace, in that workspace's timezone. If it does, it calls Slack's users.setPresence endpoint to keep you active. If it does not - it is a Saturday, it is 9pm, you turned on vacation mode - it does nothing and Slack's normal behaviour takes over.
Because that loop lives in the cloud, none of it depends on your hardware. Lid closed, machine asleep, laptop in a bag on a train, corporate VPN dropped: your presence refresh still fires. That is the same architectural choice Idle Pilot made, and it is the right one - see our auto-away prevention guide for why device-side tricks keep failing.
Setup is one screen. Head to /signin, click Continue with Slack, approve the scope, and pick your hours. Repeat for each additional workspace. No card is requested at any point, because there is nothing to charge for.
Which One Should You Pick?
- You use Microsoft Teams: choose Idle Pilot. Slackactivity cannot help you.
- You use Slack and one workspace: Slackactivity does everything you need and costs nothing, forever. Idle Pilot's lunch-break window is the main thing you would be paying for.
- You use several Slack workspaces: Slackactivity, clearly. Unlimited workspaces with independent schedules is not something a one-account tool can match.
- You care about OAuth scopes and auditability: Slackactivity uses the official Slack API with a minimal, presence-only scope you can review and revoke inside Slack.
- You want to try both: start with the free one. Slackactivity takes about 60 seconds to set up and there is nothing to cancel if you move on. Browse other head-to-head comparisons or the full guide library.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Slackactivity really free, or is there a paid tier later?
It is free forever. There is no paid plan, no trial countdown, no credit card at sign-up and no feature locked behind an upgrade. Unlimited workspaces, per-workspace schedules and vacation mode are all included at no cost.
How much does Idle Pilot cost?
At the time of writing, Idle Pilot lists a single Freedom Pass plan at $9 per month billed monthly, or $60 per year (about $5 per month) billed annually, with a 7-day free trial that does not require a credit card. Check idlepilot.com for current pricing.
Does Slackactivity work with Microsoft Teams?
No. Slackactivity is Slack-only by design. If you need Microsoft Teams presence, Idle Pilot supports Teams and is the better fit for you. If your work happens in Slack, Slackactivity covers it for free.
Can I connect more than one Slack workspace?
With Slackactivity, yes - unlimited workspaces on one dashboard, each with its own work hours, days and timezone. Idle Pilot's Freedom Pass is documented as one connected platform at a time, so multiple Slack workspaces are not its use case.
Do either of these tools read my Slack messages?
Slackactivity requests a minimal OAuth scope that only lets it set your presence - it cannot read messages, files or channels. Idle Pilot describes its access as presence-only but does not publish its OAuth scopes, so ask them directly if that matters to you.
Try the Free One First
Slackactivity keeps your Slack presence green during your work hours across unlimited workspaces - free forever, no credit card, nothing to install.
