Slack.green Alternative: Slackactivity vs Slack.green
Slackactivity is a free-forever Slack.green alternative that needs zero install: you connect with Slack's official OAuth flow and a cloud cron refreshes your presence every 5 minutes during your work hours. Slack.green offers a hosted service plus a self-hosted CLI, so the real decision is whether you want a pure cloud service you never install, or a command-line tool you run and maintain yourself.
Below is a fair, fact-checked look at both, including the one thing Slack.green does that Slackactivity does not.
What Slackactivity Does Differently
Both products solve the same annoyance: Slack's desktop client marks you away after 30 minutes of no interaction inside the Slack app, and Slack offers no setting on any plan - free or paid - to change that timeout. Where the two differ is in how the presence refresh is delivered, and what it costs.
Free Forever, Not Free For Now
Slackactivity has no paid tier. There is no trial clock, no card on file, and nothing to upgrade to. Unlimited workspaces are included because there is no plan to gate them behind.
Runs On A 5-Minute Cloud Cron
Your presence is refreshed server-side every five minutes inside your configured hours. Nothing runs on your laptop, so a closed lid, a reboot, or hotel Wi-Fi changes nothing.
Official Slack API, Minimal Scopes
It calls users.setPresence on the official Slack Web API through a Slack OAuth app, asking only for users:write and users:read. It cannot read messages, files, or channels.
Nothing To Install Or Maintain
No extension, no daemon, no CLI, no Python environment, no config file. Sign in with Slack, pick your hours and days, close the tab.
Slackactivity vs Slack.green: Side by Side
Everything in the Slack.green column comes from its own public homepage and FAQ as they read at the time of writing. Where the site does not publish something, we say so rather than guessing.
| Slackactivity | Slack.green | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free forever. No credit card, no trial, no paid tier. | No public price list on the pages we checked at the time of writing. Sign-up buttons read “Stay Green for Free” and the pricing area says “Cancel anytime”. |
| Anything to install | Nothing. Sign in with Slack in a browser and you are done. | Nothing for the hosted service. The self-hosted CLI is installed and run on your own machine. |
| Works with the laptop closed or off | Yes. A server-side cron fires every 5 minutes regardless of your device. | Hosted service: yes, it advertises running on their servers 24/7. Self-hosted CLI: only while that machine is awake and the process is running. |
| How it connects to Slack | Official Slack OAuth app. You approve it from Slack, and you can revoke it from Slack. | Its homepage describes the hosted service as running “in the cloud using browser tokens”. The CLI keeps tokens on your machine. |
| Permissions requested | users:write to set presence and users:read for your display name. It cannot read messages, files, or channels. | Not published as a scope list on the pages we reviewed. |
| Number of Slack workspaces | Unlimited, all in one dashboard. | Multi-workspace support is advertised. No published cap either way. |
| Working hours control | Per workspace: start hour, end hour, days of the week, and timezone. | Custom schedules and a continuous mode are advertised. |
| Vacation mode | Yes, pause a workspace without disconnecting it. | Not documented on the pages we reviewed. |
| Self-hosting | No. Slackactivity is a hosted service only. | Yes. A self-hosted CLI is offered for people who want to hold their own token. |
Pricing and feature details for Slack.green are described as they appeared on its public pages at the time of writing and may have changed since. Check its site before deciding.
Why Anything On Your Device Eventually Stops
This is the core architectural split, and it applies to every tool in this category - browser extensions, mouse jigglers, menu-bar apps, and self-hosted CLIs alike. If the thing that keeps you green lives on your machine, it inherits every interruption your machine has.
- A browser extension only runs while the browser runs. Quit Chrome at 6pm, restart after an OS update, or let the profile go to sleep during a long meeting and the loop stops with it. Many extensions are also throttled by the browser once a tab has been backgrounded for a while, which is precisely when you needed it.
- A CLI only runs while its process is alive. A self-hosted script is genuinely more robust than an extension, but it still needs a machine that is powered on, awake, online, and not mid-reboot. Suspend the laptop and the loop suspends too.
- Slack's timers are unforgiving. The desktop client flips you to away after 30 idle minutes, and the mobile app flips you to away almost immediately once it is backgrounded. A gap of a single lunch break is enough to show a gray dot to your whole team.
- A cron has no such gaps. Slackactivity's job runs every 5 minutes on a server whether your laptop is closed, asleep, in a bag, or switched off entirely. There is no local process to babysit.
It is worth being precise about the numbers, because they decide how much slack you actually have. Slack's desktop client waits 30 minutes of no interaction before switching your dot to away, and there is no preference, admin control, or paid-plan setting anywhere in Slack that changes it. The mobile app is stricter still: background it and you are typically away within seconds. That means a device-resident tool has to survive every gap in your day - not most of them - to look convincing. A 5-minute server-side interval clears that bar by a wide margin, and it clears it identically at 9am, at lunch, and at 4pm on a Friday when the laptop is already shut. The full mechanics are in our Slack auto-away prevention guide.
If you have already tried a jiggler or a keep-awake utility, the same logic is spelled out in our mouse jiggler alternative comparison and our guide to keeping Slack active while your computer is locked.
OAuth Scopes, And What Slackactivity Can Actually See
Slackactivity connects through a Slack OAuth app. You see the consent screen inside Slack, you approve it there, and you can revoke it from your Slack settings whenever you like - no email to support, no account deletion required. The app requests two scopes and no more:
users:write
The scope that lets the cron call users.setPresence and mark you as active. This is the entire mechanism - a documented, official Slack Web API method.
users:read
Reads your account name so the dashboard can label each connected workspace. It carries no ability to read messages, files, channels, or DMs.
Slack.green's homepage describes its hosted service as running "in the cloud using browser tokens," and its self-hosted CLI as keeping tokens on your own machine. Those are different trust models from an OAuth app, and which one you prefer is a genuine judgement call rather than a right answer - the practical difference is that a Slack OAuth grant appears in your Slack app settings with a visible scope list and a revoke button.
Where Slack.green Is The Better Pick
Being honest about this is more useful than pretending otherwise: there is one real capability Slack.green has that Slackactivity does not, and it matters to a specific kind of user.
A Self-Hosted CLI
Slack.green publishes a command-line tool that runs on your own machine with tokens stored locally. Slackactivity has no self-hosted option at all - it is a hosted service, full stop.
Full Control Of Your Token
If your policy is that a Slack credential must never sit on someone else's infrastructure, self-hosting is the right architecture and you should pick it, even though it means you own the uptime.
Pick the CLI if you are comfortable on a terminal, you have a machine or small server that genuinely stays awake all day, and you want the token under your own roof. Pick Slackactivity if you want the thing to work in two minutes, from any browser, with nothing installed and nothing to maintain - and you would rather not think about a hosting bill or a subscription, because there is neither.
One more thing worth saying plainly, because it is unusual in this category: Slackactivity is not free as an acquisition tactic with a paywall waiting behind it. There is no paid tier, no seat count, no usage meter, and no feature held back for a plan that does not exist. Unlimited workspaces, per-workspace hours, timezones, and vacation mode are all simply included, and they stay included.
Switching Takes About Two Minutes
- 1. Go to slackactivity.com/signin and click Continue with Slack.
- 2. Approve the OAuth screen. You will see exactly two scopes listed.
- 3. Set the start hour, end hour, days of the week, and timezone for that workspace.
- 4. Repeat for as many workspaces as you have. There is no limit and no per-seat charge.
- 5. Uninstall whatever was running on your laptop. You will not need it again.
Going on leave? Flip vacation mode on for a workspace instead of disconnecting it. More background is in how it works, our guides library, and the explainer on why Slack shows you as away. Remote teams in particular tend to hit this daily - see the remote worker use case.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best free Slack.green alternative?
Slackactivity. It keeps your Slack presence green during your configured work hours by calling the official Slack Web API (users.setPresence) from a cloud cron every 5 minutes, it supports unlimited workspaces, and it is 100% free forever - no credit card, no trial, and no paid tier to upgrade to.
Does Slackactivity require a browser extension or a CLI?
Neither. There is nothing to install. You go to slackactivity.com/signin, click Continue with Slack, approve the OAuth screen, and set your hours. Everything after that runs on our servers, so your laptop can be closed, asleep, or switched off.
Why does a browser extension or a local CLI stop working?
Because it lives on your device. A browser extension only executes while that browser profile is open and the machine is awake, and a CLI only runs while its process is alive. Close the lid, reboot, or lose Wi-Fi and the loop stops. Slack then applies its normal 30-minute desktop idle timeout and flips you to away.
Is a self-hosted CLI ever the better choice?
Yes, for some people. If your rule is that your Slack token must never leave hardware you control, a self-hosted CLI like the one Slack.green offers is a legitimately better fit than any hosted service, including ours. The trade-off is that you own the uptime: the machine has to stay awake and online for the whole workday.
Can Slackactivity read my Slack messages?
No. The OAuth scopes it requests are users:write, which sets your presence, and users:read, which reads your account name so the dashboard can label the workspace. Those scopes give no access to messages, files, or channels, and you can revoke the app from your Slack settings at any time.
Free Forever, With Nothing To Install
Connect Slack, set your hours, and stay green during your workday - unlimited workspaces, no credit card, no paid tier.
